The Far Cry
Frederic Brown | Black Lizard | 1987 (first published 1951) | 176 pages
Seeking solitude to recuperate from an alcohol-fueled mental breakdown, George Weaver rents an isolated cabin in Taos, New Mexico, for a summer of psychological rest before returning to work and family in Kansas City. His rental, the last shack on a lonely, dead-end road into the mountains, was the site of a murder eight years prior, and had been unoccupied until his arrival.
Jenny Ames, a young girl responding to a lonely hearts ad, was murdered by Charles Nelson, the cabin’s former occupant, who then fled town and subsequently vanished. A true-crime writer friend of George convinces him to investigate the murder while recovering in Taos, with the goal of selling a story to the pulp magazines. What starts as a casual dalliance into the case quickly escalates into a full-blown obsession, as George tries to trace Jenny’s mysterious origins and track her killer.
The mundane details of George’s daily life set the stage for a bored mind seeking the diversion of a mystery. Coffee and eggs in the morning, light maintenance work on the cabin, and runs into town to talk to those who remember the case. Plus the drinking. Lots of drinking.
George’s role as a neutral amateur detective becomes somewhat shaded as he unearths more details about Nelson, and several parallels between the two men’s characters begin to surface. George reveals himself as a complete heel when his wife Vi arrives to spend the rest of the summer with him while their two children are away at summer camp. Although showing great compassion towards Jenny, George possesses a seething contempt for Vi, repeatedly describing her as bovine, sloppy, and dim-witted. Her arrival drives him further away, out of the cabin and away from her blaring radio, and deeper into the investigation of the murder.
George’s obsession with Jenny is comparable to Dana Andrew’s infatuation with the murdered woman in Otto Preminger’s Laura (1944). He even begins to imagine an alternate history where he meets Jenny on the bus prior to her fateful arrival in Taos, ultimately preventing her destiny from being buried in a shallow grave. As George becomes more consumed by thoughts of the tragic young woman, even the pretext of writing an article falls away, leaving him naked with his morbid fascinations and perhaps heading towards another breakdown.
The twin mysteries revolving around both victim and suspect are engrossing enough for the chapters to fly by, even as George’s likeability as a main character sours accordingly along the way. Vi is simply a one-note caricature—getting drunk, eating candies, and flipping through magazines—but his bitter insults towards her are nevertheless wince inducing. George’s perceptions, however warped, of the real versus the idealized woman remain a key foundation to the story.
The final pages contain a love-it-or-hate-it twist which tidily closes the circle on the narrative even as it stretches credibility. For those who hate it, however, the veracity of the logical jump could easily be argued as the delusions of an unreliable narrator.
The shock ending may firmly land The Far Cry in thriller territory, but it is also a gripping psychological noir mood piece, evocatively realized and crafted—it’s hard not to imagine Elizabeth Taylor as Jenny and Shelley Winters as Vi, as their A Place in the Sun (1951) characters mash with Lost Weekend (1945).